Search our Site:
Energy Manitoba logo Climate Action Network Canada logo
 Sign up for
 Notices here

 
Manitoba Wildlands logo




News

KI, Ring of Fire, and Resource Sovereignty 30 November 12

In 2006, Ontario First Nation, Kitchenuhmaykoosib Inninuwug (KI), said 'no' to a mining company. KI was sued for $10 billion, its leaders were found in contempt of court and jailed. Three years later, the Ontario government paid the company $5 million to go away.

The traditional area KI is located in is called the "Ring of Fire" by exploration companies. Discovery of extensive chromite deposits along with nickel and copper near McFaulds Lake and the Attawapiskat River have raised the possibility of large and long-term developments in a remote area on the fringe of the Hudson Bay Lowlands.

In July 2011, KI held a community referendum and, passed into law a declaration that in effect "nationalized" all the resources on their homelands and protected all the waters flowing in and out of Big Trout Lake watershed, in the core of their homeland. This is a Canadian first.

With exploration and mining companies expecting substantial subsidies from the Ontario government, taxpayers will potentially be on the hook for millions of dollars. No proper assessment of infrastructure needs and environmental impact assessments have been done to date. The costs for clean up after the mining companies have left are unknown.

View No Means No: The Kitchenuhmaykoosib Inninuwug and the Fight for Resource Sovereignty
View November 26, 2012 MiningWatch Canada article
View September 27, 2012 The Star article
View June 27, 2012 The Star article
View National Post article
Share printer Print version Top

CEAA Invites Comments on Keeyask 30 November 12

Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency (CEAA) invites public comments on the potential environmental effects of the Keeyask Generation Project and the proposed measures to prevent or mitigate those effects. Written comments are due by December 21, 2012.

Following this comment period, CEAA will prepare the Comprehensive Study Report, setting out its conclusions on the environmental effects, the proposed mitigation measures and the significance of any remaining adverse environmental effects. A public comment period on the Comprehensive Study Report will be announced at a later date.

The proposed Keeyask Generation Project, is a $5.6 billion 695-megawatt hydroelectric dam, slated for development by Keeyask Hydro Power Limited Partnership (between Manitoba Hydro and four nearby Manitoba First Nations) on the Nelson River at Gull Rapids near Gillam, Manitoba.

Modern dams in Manitoba require at least three licenses. Two licenses from the Manitoba government: a Water Power Act license, and an Environment Act License; plus a federal permit under the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act (CEAA).

The federal environmental assessment also considers a proposal by Manitoba Hydro for a 22 kilometre transmission line to provide construction power to the Keeyask Generation Project and three 35 kilometre long transmission lines within a single corridor to transmit electricity from the Keeyask Generation Project to the existing Radisson Converter Station near Gillam, Manitoba.

Unlike CEAA, the Manitoba Government Environmental Approvals Branch is attempting to license the Keeyask Infrastructure, Keeyask Generation, and Keeyask Transmission projects separately.

View November 21, 2012 Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency (CEAA) Public Notice
View Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency (CEAA), Keeyask Generating Station Reference Number 11-03-64144
View Keeyask Hydro Power Limited Partnership website
View Manitoba Wildlands Manitoba Hyrdo Projects page
Source: Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency
Share printer Print version Top

Stop the War on Science: Save the ELA 30 November 12

Scientists, activists, and concerned citizens are sending a clear message it is time to stop Canada's war on science. One of the most devastating losses to Canada's science capacity is defunding of the Experimental Lakes Area (ELA) research center and the dismantling of its scientific team. The Coalition to Save ELA released a video about the Canadian government's war on science which urges Canadians to defend public science and save Canada's Experimental Lakes Area.

"Cutting the ELA – the only research center capable of providing a solid science basis for freshwater policy – is extremely short-sighted," insists award-winning, world-renowned freshwater expert Dr. David Schindler, Killam Memorial Chair in Ecology, University of Alberta.

"The Harper government is gutting all and any tools, rules, and science projects that stand in the way of corporate abuse of our freshwater heritage," says Maude Barlow, National Chairperson of the Council of Canadians. "No ELA means that the damage done to water from extractive industries will forever be hidden."

"This is the only place in the world where lakes have been set aside to build a research base to save our planet's threatened freshwater – and so we must save ELA," concludes Dr. Jon Gerrard, Leader of the Manitoba Liberal Party.

"We need to stop this war on science, and let's start by saving the ELA," asserts Diane Orihel, Director of the Coalition to Save ELA.

Watch November 27, 2012 Save The ELA video video
Visit Save ELA website
View Save the ELA Facebook page
View Save the ELA Twitter page
View November 9, 2012 Metro article
View October 18, 2012 CBC News article
Share printer Print version Top

Manitoba's New Clean Energy Strategy 30 November 12

Innovation, Energy and Mines Minister Dave Chomiak announced a new energy strategy for Manitoba. What Matters Most: Manitoba's Clean Energy Strategy was released November 20, 2012.

"This strategy is all about making energy choices today that will create a stronger economy and a cleaner environment for our future. Is fossil fuel freedom achievable? We're closer than you might think," stated Chomiak.

Priorities the Manitoba Government identified in the strategy include:

  • Building a new generation of hydropower projects in Manitoba's north.
  • Improving energy efficiency within Mantoba.
  • Expanding renewable energy alternatives such as wind, solar, geothermal, and biomass.
  • Promoting the uses of ethanol, biodiesel, pure electric and hybrid vehicles.

"We certainly do need to wean ourselves from dependence on fossil fuels. There are both good and not so good aspects to this strategy, but with public input it could have been significantly improved. It is unfortunate this strategy was released without any opportunities for public input," said Manitoba Wildlands Director Gaile Whelan Enns.

View November 20, 2012 Government of Manitoba What Matters Most: Manitoba's Clean Energy Strategy (PDF)
View November 20, 2012 Government of Manitoba press release
View November 22, 2012 Portage Daily Graphic coverage
View Manitoba Wildlands Governments page
Source: Government of Manitoba
Share printer Print version Top

International Climate Talks Begin in Doha, Qatar Begin 23 November 12

The annual two-week conference required by United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), an agreement adopted by virtually every country in the world in 1992 is set to begin.

Doha 2012, this year's annual United Nations Climate Change Conference, will be held Monday, November 26th to Friday, December 7th 2012 at the Qatar National Convention Centre in Doha, Qatar.

The central goal of Doha 2012 is to build upon the so-called "Durban Platform" agreed to at the end of UNFCCC conference in Durban, South Africa (Durban 2011). In Durban Governments agreed to establish a new legally binding agreement structure by 2015. A new binding agreement is not expected to be concluded at Doha 2012, but it is hoped discussions will help establish the framework for an agreement.

The European Union (EU), Australia, Norway, Switzerland and a handful of other countries are expected to sign up for a second commitment period under the Kyoto Protocol (a sub-agreement of the UNFCCC signed at the 1997 annual conference in Kyoto, Japan that set binding obligations on industrialized countries to reduce their emissions of GHGs). But earlier Kyoto Protocol signatories such as Canada, Russia, and Japan are refusing to sign-on for a second commitment period.

Manitoba Wildlands will be providing selected and recommended links for news, reports, and analysis regarding the Doha 2012 UN Climate Summit: November-December 2012. Visit our page content for more information.

View Manitoba Wildlands, COP 18 - Doha 2012 page
View Official Doha 2012 - COP 18 page
View UNFCCC Doha 2012 - COP 18 page
View Climate Action Network International (CANET)
Sources: Manitoba Wildlands
Share printer Print version Top

Climate Reports Forecast Dire Climate Future 23 November 12

A number of leading organizations are issuing reports that predict it may be too late for runaway global warming even in the face of dramatic action. Pricewaterhouse Cooper, the World bank and the International Energy Agency have each issued separate warnings.

As global warming approaches and exceeds 2-degrees Celsius, there is a risk of triggering nonlinear tipping elements. Examples include the disintegration of the West Antarctic ice sheet leading to more rapid sea-level rise, or large-scale Amazon dieback drastically affecting ecosystems, rivers, agriculture, energy production, and livelihoods.

Atmospheric levels of carbon dioxide are at an all-time high and are projected to continue booming. Many scientists feel global warming of 2 degrees or greater is inevitable.

Internationally renowned business firm Pricewaterhouse Coopers, issued a report, titled "Too Late for Two Degrees?." The report suggested that current efforts to reduce the carbon intensity, or the amount of emissions per unit of GDP, are unfolding so slowly as to be negligible.

The Paris-based International Energy Agency (IEA), suggested in its annual World Energy Outlook that even accounting for the policy commitments already made or contemplated by world governments, energy-related emissions are expected to continue to rise over the next two decades, pointing to a "long‐term average temperature increase of 3.6 degrees Celsius.

A World Bank report entitled, "Turn Down the Heat: Why a 4°c Warmer World Must Be Avoided", suggests that the climate could warm a full 4 degrees by the end of the century even if countries fulfill the modest emissions-reduction pledges they've already made.

"Lack of action on climate change threatens to make the world our children inherit a completely different world than we are living in today," said World Bank Group President Jim Yong Kim.

"It is still possible to avoid 2-degree warming, and arguing it is too late could very easily be a self-fulfilling prophecy," said Michael E. Mann, a climatologist and director of the Earth System Science Center at Pennsylvania State University. "That having been said, the real issue is whether or not we have the political will."

"It would take an incredible effort, but that's what we're trying to spur," said author and activist from 350.org Bill McKibben, "Given the damage that 1 degree is doing, we're already at 'dire,'" McKibben said. "We dearly don't want to see what 2 degrees looks like, much less 3."

View November 21, 2012 Huffington Post coverage
View November 18, 2012 World Bank report
View November 12, 2012 International Energy Agency (IEA) report
View November 1, 2012 Pricewaterhouse Coopers report
Sources: Huffington Post
Share printer Print version Top

IKEA Vows All Solar and Wind Power 23 November 12

IKEA, the world's largest furniture retailer, is investing 1.5 billion euros ($1.95 billion) from 2009 to 2015 in solar and wind power.

IKEA already owns wind farms in six European nations and has 342,000 solar panels on its stores, warehouses and factories that generate 27% of the company's electricity. IKEA hopes to increase this to 70% by 2015, and 100% by 2020.

"We know we're going to be using energy in 20 years' time," said IKEA Chief Sustainability Officer Steve Howard. "If we can own our own renewable energy plants ... it gives us complete price certainty."

The initiative is part of IKEA's People & Planet Positive strategy, which aims to satisfy consumer demand for more sustainable products, while also saving money for both IKEA and its clients.

The People & Planet Positive strategy also calls for IKEA, one of the world's top users of wood, to grow at least as many trees as it uses to make products such as beds or cupboards by 2020. Already, IKEA says it does not take wood from natural tropical forests, such as in the Amazon or the Congo basins.

"With the opening of IKEA in Winnipeg we can look forward to IKEA wind turbines in Manitoba too," said Gaile Whelan-Enns Director of Manitoba Wildlands.

John Sauven, head of Greenpeace UK, said the People & Planet Positive strategy "puts IKEA at the forefront of leading companies" trying to transform their businesses in the face of environmental threats.

View October 23, 2012 IKEA press release
View October 25, 2012 Global Fund Exchange, Future of Energy blog
View October 24, 2012 National Geograhic, Great Energy Challenge blog
View October 23, 2012 Reuters coverage
View October 23, 2012 USA Today coverage
Sources: IKEA, Reuters
Share printer Print version Top

China Deal Assaulting Canadian Environment and Democracy 23 November 12

The Canada-China Financial Investment Promotion and Protection (FIPA) trade deal being brokered in secret backroom negotiations has the potential to severely undermine Canadian sovereignty at all levels of government. It is being brokered without review by the House of Commons or the public. The FIPA deal with China opens the door for Chinese state-owned corporations to sue any level of Canadian government, in secret tribunals, for loss of profits compensation.

As a result, this trade deal allows companies from China to ignore Canada's environmental laws and regulations in pursuit of profits from natural resource extraction.

The FIPA with China is, one sided in China's favour. The agreement Article 4 allows China to bypass and contest provincial, territorial, First Nations, municipal or successive federal government decisions on resource and commercial management. If the National Energy Board approves the Northern Gateway Pipeline through B.C., but B.C. restricts or rejects the deal, Sinopec can sue under this treaty. The matter would then be resolved behind closed doors in arbitration by two lawyers from outside Canada.

FIPAs are treaties between two nations that impose binding obligations on both countries with respect to their treatment of foreign investors and investment. They generally provide guarantees pertaining to non-discriminatory treatment, expropriation, transfer of funds, transparency, due process and dispute settlement.

Matthew Carroll, the campaign director for Leadnow.ca, said the secrecy in the process is just part of the concern. The Canada-China FIPA agreement allows the partner governments to keep lawsuits and settlements private — which is not the case with the North American Free Trade Agreement.

"If a Canadian government is sued under NAFTA, that becomes public information. But it's entirely up to the discretion of our government whether or not they make the information under this FIPA public," he said.

View November 2, 2012 Financial Post article
View October 31, 2012 Ottawa Citizen article
View October 31, 2012 Ottawa Citizen article
View October 30, 2012 Huffington Post article
View October 26, 2012 De Smog Blog post
View October 22, 2012 The Province article
View October 17, 2012 Huffington Post article
View Stephen Harper's Assault on Democracy
View January 11, 2010 National Union of Public and General Employees article
Share printer Print version Top

CEC Bipole III Hearings Adjourned Until March 2013 16 November 12

During week seven of the Clean Environment Commission CEC) hearings regarding the Bipole III DC transmission system, proposed by Manitoba Hydro, the CEC chair announced an upcoming adjournment until March 2013. The announcement was made Tuesday, November 13, 2012.

During week five of the CEC hearings Manitoba Hydro revealed it was making three changes in the route for the Bipole III corridor. A presentation about the route changes was made during the hearing, and is recorded in the transcript. Questions regarding environmental statements (EIS), full information, additional requirements on participants, review of these route changes by the public and hearing participants went into the record.

Letters on November 2 and November 9 addressed to Manitoba Hydro from the director of licensing for the Environment Act clarified that EIS materials will be filed under the Environment Act, and undergo the usual reviews.

Manitoba Hydro has to file the EIS to support these route changes by January 28, 2013. The chair of the CEC, Mr. T Sargent, has indicated that hearings will resume in early March, 2013. Due to the adjournment on November 22, 2012, closing statements from participants are held over until hearings resume in March 2013.

Share printer Print version Top

Environment Hearings & Economic Review for Dams Announced 16 November 12

The Manitoba government made two announcements about Hydro projects November 12, 2012.

Minister Gord MacKintosh referred the Keeyask Generation Station and transmission system to the Clean Environment Commission (CEC) for review and public hearings. The minister acknowledges that the Canadian Environment Assessment Agency will undertake an assessment of the project.

Public comments on the Environment Impact Statement (EIS) for the Keeyask dam and its transmission are due December 21, 2012. A technical advisory committee (TAC) made up of both federal and provincial agencies also reviews the EIS and provides technical review comments. All correspondence, the EIS, TAC and public review comments are part of the public registry file under the Environment Act.

The terms of reference for the CEC hearings were also released, and are available on the conservation department webpage. The CEC will post information, set schedules, seek participants for the hearings in the near future. The hearings will occur in affected communities and in Winnipeg. Participant funding will be available.

A second announcement by Minister MacKintosh directs the Public Utility Board to conduct a 'Needs for and Alternatives To' review of: Keeyask and Conawapa generation stations, and associated transmission facilities. No mention of export sale agreements, or the transmission line required for recent export sales to Wisconsin appears in the press release.

A Public Utilities Board sub panel will conduct the review. Terms of reference will be public in early 2013.

View November 14, 2012 Minister of Conservation and Water Stewardship letter to CEC
View November 16, 2012 Government of Manitoba news release
View November 16, 2012 Government of Manitoba news release
Share printer Print version Top

BP Settlement and Criminal Charges 16 November 12

British Petroleum (BP) owner of the Deepwater Horizon exploration drill rig that exploded and sank in the Gulf of Mexico in April of 2010, has reached agreement with the U.S. Department of Justice. BP has pleaded guilty to fourteen felony charges related to the Deepwater Horizon explosion. The agreement with the U.S. Department of Justice includes eleven charges of manslaughter related to the deaths of workers on the Deepwater Horizon rig, and a felony count of obstruction of justice for lying to U.S. Congress about the amount of oil leaking from the damaged well.

BP is to pay $4.5 billion dollars in fines over the next five years as well as being made to report to an operations monitor for the next four years, and update all its safety equipment and procedures on all its oil rigs. The fine handed to BP is the largest in American history.

Three former BP employees have been charged with separate felony counts. Donald Vidrine and Robert Kaluza, BP drilling managers overseeing operations on Deepwater Horizon, were charged with 22 counts of negligent manslaughter for the deaths of the 11 rig workers. Former BP vice president in charge of exploration in the Gulf of Mexico, David Rainey, was charged with felony obstruction of justice for allegedly lying to Congress and federal law enforcement officials about the amount of oil leaking from the well.

View November 15, 2012 Attorney General Eric Holder speech at the BP Press Conference
View November 15, 2012 Huffington Post article
View November 15, 2012 British Petroleum press release
View November 15, 2012 CBC News article
View November 19, 2012 PlanetArk article
Share printer Print version Top

Atlas of Health and Climate Released by WHO 16 November 12

The World Health Organization and the World Meterological Organization collaborated to create the new Atlas of Health and Climate released in Geneva October 29, 2012. The WMO Congress in Geneva, where the Atlas was releaed, discussed the Global Framework for Climate Services. The Atlas illustrates some of the world's most pressing challenges. It provides sound scientific information on the connections between weather and climate and major health challenges.

At 68 pages, the Atlas gives practical examples of how weather and climate information can protect public health in the face of climate variability and extreme weather events. Links between health and climate are shown in maps, tables, graphics.

"Stronger cooperation between the meterological and health communities is essential to ensure that up to date, accurate and relevant information on weather and climate is integrated into public health management at international, national and local levels." said WMO Secretary General Mr. Michel Jarraud.

View 2012 WHO/WMO report Atlas of health and climate
Share printer Print version Top



Manitoba Wildlands2002-2014