Manitoba Wildlands  
Phosphorus Removal Will Save Lake 23 January 09

Lake Winnipeg imageScientists say there is no need to remove nitrogen from Winnipeg's sewage. In a letter to the provincial Clean Environment Commission, more than 60 internationally recognized aquatic scientists say Manitoba should rethink its plans for saving Lake Winnipeg.

The Manitoba government has ordered an overhaul on Winnipeg's wastewater treatment system to the tune of $1.8 billion. An extra $50 million will be spent on treatment processes to remove nitrogen from wastewater that ends up in Lake Winnipeg.

"We disagree with the government's plans to improve the health of Lake Winnipeg by making minor reductions in inputs of both phosphorus and nitrogen, rather than making much larger reductions in phosphorus alone," the scientists said.

Scientists say the blooms of blue-green algae plaguing Lake Winnipeg are a result of phosphorus and not nitrogen. The letter originated at an October 2008 conference at the University of Winnipeg organized by the Lake Winnipeg Foundation.

View December 19, 2008 Scientist's Lake Winnipeg Letter to the CEC (PDF)
View December 21, 2008 - Scientists attack nitrogen plan
View Winnipeg Wastewater Nutrient Reduction
View 2008 CBC Series: A Sea of Troubles - Lake Winnipeg in Crisis
View December 12, 2007 Lake Winnipeg Foundation, Questions and comments about removal of nitrogen and phosphorus from Winnipeg Sewage (PDF)
View Lake Winnipeg Stewardship Board website

Sources: Winnipeg Free Press, CEC, CBC, Lake Winnipeg Foundation, Lake Winnipeg Stewardship Board
   Print version Top


Manitoba Wildlands2002-2014