Search our Site:
 
  Advanced

 Sign up for
 Notices here

Donations
 
Manitoba Wildlands logo


Environmental Licensing
Winnipeg Floodway
National Energy Board
Energy Development
Wuskwatim Projects
Future Hydro Projects
Historic Hydro Gallery
Hydro Research
Hydro Map Gallery
Mining
Transportation
Sustainable Development

Energy Development

Top

Manitoba Hydro Overview

Manitoba Hydro LogoEnergy production and distribution in Manitoba is inextricably linked to its sole Crown-owned utility. Manitoba Hydro serves 510 000 electric customers throughout Manitoba and 258 000 natural gas customers in various communities throughout southern Manitoba.
Source: Manitoba Hydro
The utility has several roles:
  • electricity production (water power, thermal generation, natural gas, diesel)
  • electricity purchase (wind sources)
  • electricity delivery (transmission system)
  • electricity export (provinces, US)
  • electricity import (provinces, US)
  • natural gas purchasing (import), distribution (pipeline system)
  • promotion and support for energy conservation (Power Smart programs)
  • exploration and support for other sources of clean, renewable energy (geo-thermal heat pumps)
Manitoba Hydro (as the name implies) was originally primarily a hydro-electricity company and this function still dominates its operation. When it purchased Winnipeg Hydro, an electrical utility previously owned by the City of Winnipeg, in 2002, it became the only provider (generation and transmission) of hydro-electricity in the province. With the acquisition of Centra Gas in 1999, Manitoba Hydro became the primary supplier of natural gas for industrial, commercial and residential use in Manitoba. The publicly owned corporation claims that Manitobans enjoy the lowest energy costs in North America.

Electricity Production
Manitoba Dam Close to 98% of the electricity Manitoba Hydro generates is produced by the 14 hydroelectric generating stations on the Nelson, Winnipeg, Saskatchewan and Laurie Rivers. Approximately 2% of Manitoba Hydro's electricity is produced by two thermal generating stations and four remote diesel generating stations.
Source: Manitoba Hydro

In total, Manitoba Hydro's electric power generating capacity is 5,481MW, and of this 4,998MW comes from hydroelectric generating stations.

Electricity Purchase
Manitoba Hydro purchases electricity generated by wind turbines - as of February 2007, Manitoba is generating 103.95MW of electricity from Phase 1 and Phase 2 of the St. Leon project.

Wind power therefore constitutes just under 2% of Manitoba's total electricity generation capacity. In 2005, and again in 2006 the Manitoba Government committed to the development of 1,000MW of wind power over the next decade.
Other proposed wind projects are being reviewed under the Environment Act (see New Renewable Energy - Wind Energy below). Agreements must also be in place between independent power producers and Manitoba Hydro in order to facilitate the integration of this power into Manitoba Hydro's transmission system. To date there are no public environmental statement standards for wind developers to fulfill for their Manitoba environmental license.

Electricity Delivery
Manitoba Hydro has extensive infrastructure to support the delivery of power in the province. There is roughly 11,000km of transmission corridors throughout the province, outside towns and cities.

The transmission system transports electricity at high voltages from the generating stations to other parts of Manitoba Hydro's provincial power system, as well as to other utilities' power systems. The distribution system transforms the higher voltages to useable levels for delivery to customers, and maintains steady voltage levels in spite of continuously changing demands for power during the course of a day or a season.

Electricity Export
There are 12 points or interconnections between Manitoba Hydro's transmission infrastructure and the electricity grids of other Canadian provinces and the US. They provide the capacity for Manitoba to import approximately 850MW and export 2,600MW of power.

Manitoba Hydro claims that their ability to export surplus power is a major factor in keeping Manitobans' electricity costs at low rates.

Natural Gas Purchasing and Distribution
Manitoba Hydro-owned Centra Gas purchases natural gas from suppliers and delivers the gas to Manitoba consumers. In order to move the gas to where it is needed, Centra maintains 1674 km of transmission pipeline and 6496 km of distribution pipeline.
Source: Manitoba Hydro

Promotion and Support for Energy Conservation
Manitoba Hydro Mural October 2003 Manitoba Hydro has an energy conservation strategy (also known as 'demand-side management') called 'Power Smart' (please also see section below on New Renewable Energy - Energy Conservation). The objective of Power Smart is to meet energy needs through efficiency improvements rather than new sources of generation. Through Power Smart, Manitoba Hydro promotes energy efficient products, services and programs for residential, commercial and industrial customers.

Exploration and Support for Other Sources of Clean, Renewable Energy
Manitoba Hydro's Earth Power Loan Program is designed to provide assistance to Manitobans wishing to install geothermal heat pumps. Geothermal heat pumps, often referred to as GeoExchange or Earth Energy, use a system of pipes buried below the frost line, where the ground is warmer in winter and cooler in summer to provide heating and cooling for homes and businesses. They emit 66% less greenhouse gases than conventional heating and cooling systems that use fossil fuels and use up to 75% less electricity, reducing annual heating and cooling costs by 50% - 70%.

Installations have tripled over four years and Manitoba has become a leader in earth energy systems.

solar panels Manitoba does not have any programs in place to promote residential or commercial installations of solar energy, nor does it have an electricity feed law that would permit individuals to connect their solar power systems to the grid and pay them a fair price to 'feed' electricity back into the grid when not being used by the household.

Manitoba Energy Plan

Top
The Province of Manitoba does not have an energy plan, or specific public policy regarding domestic energy needs, and conservation targets. Nor is there a new renewable portfolio standard or mandated objective for new sources of renewable energy production in the province.

During the absence of these public policy tools, various Manitoba Hydro development intentions/proposals continue to be actively discussed, planned, and/or proposed. These projects, if approved, have the potential to alter significant tracts of our northern boreal forest ecosystems. They are being planned without completed networks of protected areas in these forest regions. The government's development intentions are geared towards serving out-of-province/ export energy markets. Manitoba currently has sufficient energy for domestic purposes.

In 2002, a new provincial Department of Energy, Science and Technology (EST) was created.
Visit Manitoba Department of Energy, Science and Technology website
Visit Manitoba Hydro website
View Manitoba government press releases about Manitoba Hydro

Manitoba's need for an energy plan was recognized by the Manitoba Chambers of Commerce (MCC), which called, in 2006, for a public dialogue to arrive at an energy plan for Manitoba.

The MCC passed a resolution - An Energy Plan for Manitoba at its 75th Annual General Meeting (AGM) March 2006.

One of the primary objectives of the MCC resolution would be to "define environmental protection and conservation of our natural ecosystems as primary considerations in terms of energy use in Manitoba."

As Manitoba's largest business lobby, the MCC represents 74 communities and over 10,000 businesses across Manitoba through direct corporate membership and local chambers.

downloadDownload the March 2006 Manitoba Chambers of Commerce resolution An Energy Plan for Manitoba (PDF)
Visit the Manitoba Chambers of Commerce web site

New Renewable Energy

Top
In spring 2002, the Manitoba government established a new agency responsible for the development of alternative energy options. This agency will be responsible for both renewable energy like hydro, and the new renewables such as wind, solar, ethanol, geothermal, etc.

Visit the Manitoba Government's Energy Development Initiative web site

The Manitoba Government has taken some initial steps to promote the development of alternative and new renewable sources of energy. In this section we are providing information on government programs and initiatives related to this commitment to energy alternatives as well as energy development project that have been proposed or are in the process of being licensed.

Energy Conservation
Conservation is an often overlooked but very important source of alternative energy. The modest Manitoba Hydro Power Smart Program, has not realized the full potential of demand side management (DSM) opportunities. The Manitoba government and Manitoba Hydro have not yet invested sufficiently in energy conservation.

Visit Manitoba Hydro's PowerSmart pages
Visit the following sites for energy efficiency and DSM best practices:
Best Practices Benchmarking for Energy Efficiency Programs
Canadian Energy Efficiency Centre

Hydrogen
Manitoba Wildlands reviewed the Manitoba Energy Science and Technology Hydrogen Discussion paper.

downloadDownload An Evaluation of Preliminary Hydrogen Opportunities Report (PDF)
View the Preliminary Hydrogen Opportunities Report

Wind Energy
As of February 2008, eleven wind energy projects have been proposed or licensed under Manitoba's Environment Act. field of windmills Concerns have been raised because ten of the eleven projects licensed or in the process of obtaining an environmental licence in Manitoba are 99 MW projects. This avoids classification as a Class 3 development (projects under 100 MW are Class 2 developments) under the Environment Act, resulting in lower licensing fees, less public involvement, no public hearings, and no EIS Guidelines.

Changes proposed to the Environment Act would remove the 100 MW threshold for wind projects regarding class of development and classify all wind project greater than 2 MW as Class 2 developments. This step would cancel having any standard of environmental assessment for wind projects, no matter the total footprint or size of these projects. The role of the public in contributing to the environmental review and assessment process would also be cancelled.

Currently, despite political commitments to avoid staged environmental licenses in Manitoba, these 99 MW project developers assume they can add to their projects without having to be assessed, etc. Also there are no public EIS standards in Manitoba for wind energy projects. An example of what this means is that there are no set back standards.

Manitoba Wildlands has provided comments on some of the wind energy projects that have or are been assessed under Manitoba's Environment Act.

downloadDownload Manitoba Wildlands/CNF October 17, 2003 comments: Sequoia Energy Inc. - St. Leon Wind-Energy Project (PDF)
downloadDownload Manitoba Wildlands/CNF December 12, 2003 appeal of the November 14, 2003 environmental license for Sequoia Energy Inc. - St. Leon Wind-Energy Project (PDF)
downloadDownload Manitoba Wildlands' March 8, 2006 comments: Killarney Wind Energy Project (PDF)
downloadDownload Manitoba Wildlands' April 12, 2006 comments: Dacotah Wind Energy Project (PDF)

Other individuals and groups, including landowners/farmers in Manitoba have also raised concerns and provided comments on wind energy projects that have are being licensed under Manitoba's Environment Act.

Some of the concerns raised by farmers and landowners about effects from the 99 MW Swan Lake Wind Energy Project (Greenwing Energy Development L.P.) include:
  • public participation has not been adequate - e.g. problems exist with regard to accessing information; public comment period too limited
  • the developer will not release information to support its claim that they have the support of a majority of landowners in the area
  • landowners who are not participating in the project will be subject to many of the same restrictions (without compensation) as participating landowners
Other information for landowners considering agreements to develop wind power on their lands or whose lands may be affected: The Manitoba Government has committed to the development of 1,000MW of wind power over the next decade. The province and Manitoba Hydro issued an invitation for expressions of interest (EOI) from proponents for potential wind-power projects of more than 10 megawatts (MW) and up to 1,000 MW in November 2005. The initial deadline of January 20, 2006 was extended to February 24, 2006.

View the November 21, 2005 Government of Manitoba press release

CanWEA logo The invitation for expressions of interest in wind power projects resulted in 36 responses from 43 proponents including wind developers, First Nations, communities, turbine manufacturers and consultants.

View the March 10, 2006 Government of Manitoba press release

In September 2006, the Manitoba Government took the next step towards its goal of 1,000 MW of wind power, announcing another request for proposals for 300 MW to take place in winter 2006-07.

View the September 7, 2006 Government of Manitoba press release

The Canadian Wind Energy Association (CanWEA) maintains up to date information regarding installed wind project and wind projects that have been contracted or are under construction.

View a chart of installed wind capacity by province
downloadDownload a chart of Canadian Wind Energy Projects with a Signed Power Purchase Agreement and/or Already Under Construction (PDF)

Manitoba Hydro – Development Intentions

Top
Manitoba Hydro is signatory to a number of agreements or treaties with First Nation and other Aboriginal communities in northern and central Manitoba, where generation stations have been established on rivers, and where lakes have become reservoirs. One such agreement is the 1977 Northern Flood Agreement signed between Canada, Manitoba, Manitoba Hydro, and five northern First Nations communities affected by generation stations, flooding, and environmental impacts.

See our Consultations/Licenses page, and links regarding environmental licenses above for information about the Manitoba Hydro license application for Wuskwatim generation station and transmission line projects. See Manitoba Hydro for maps of the hydroelectric system in Manitoba and information regarding the corporation's development intentions.

Current major development intentions include:
  • Wuskwatim Generation Project
  • Wuskwatim Transmission Project
  • Conawapa Generation Project
  • Bipole III Transmission Corridor
  • Gull (Keeyask) Generation Project
  • East-West Power Transmission Grid
  • Notigi Generation Project
  • Gillam Island Generation Project
Manitoba Hydro - Current & Potential Interconnections
Hydro connectiveness map
Larger Image

Manitoba Wildlands has mapped both existing and potential transmission lines/corridors for Manitoba. See the inset map (right) regarding unknown transmission lines for new dams on the Nelson River. Citations and sources are listed on the main map (above right). Potential Hydro Transmission - East Side of Lake Winnipeg
Hydro potential transmission
Larger Image

Wuskwatim Projects

  For information click here

Future Projects - Manitoba Hydro

  For information click here

Historic Hydro Gallery

MB Hydro dam in ManitobaManitoba Wildlands has designed a photo gallery that shows communities and rivers across northern Manitoba, starting as early as 1880, to show before, during, and after images of hydro generation development in our province.

For information click here

Hydro Research

  For information click here

Hydro Map Gallery

  For information click here

Comment

comment

Manitoba Hydro: 10 things Manitobans need to know

Manitoba Hydro LogoManitoba Hydro's development plans are a constant feature of media coverage, in particular because of a growing preoccupation with climate change and messaging that portrays hydroelectric power as climate-friendly. Some content implies that new dams in Manitoba will deliver on Kyoto obligations by exporting energy. Manitoba Hydro is actively planning new hydroelectric dams and transmission lines. The licensing process for the first of a 'new generation' of hydro projects - the Wuskwatim Generating Station and Transmission projects began in November 2001. Federal approvals and provincial environment licences were issued summer 2006.

Manitoba Hydro is a public utility owned by all Manitoba residents. The utility also owns natural gas distribution for the province. Every Manitoban is affected by Manitoba Hydro's investment decisions and debt load.

10 facts each Manitoban should know:
  1. Manitoba does not have an energy plan.
  2. Hydro power through large dams and reservoirs is not clean, new renewable energy. Generation and transmission of hydroelectric energy produces less greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) than fossil fuel energy sources. GHG are produced in construction of dams & roads, when land is flooded, and through ongoing erosion, and changes in water levels. Various environmental and social consequences persist as a result of permanently altering water flows and changing ecosystem functions.
  3. Manitoba currently has enough electricity to meet its needs for many years into the future, especially with energy conservation measures. Manitoba Hydro proposes to export the power generated by the Wuskwatim dam to out-of-province customers for several years. Information about export planning, and resource use planning by Manitoba Hydro is not available to the public.
  4. Manitoba Hydro is currently planning at least four new hydroelectric dams in northeastern Manitoba. Each requires an environmental license. Each licensing process takes years to complete. Each has both federal and provincial assessment requirements.
  5. All new hydroelectric dams must comply with the federal Canadian Environmental Assessment Act (CEAA) as well as the Manitoba Environment Act. The Wuskwatim hydroelectric dam is the first project in Manitoba to be licensed under either Act. Under the federal CEAA, "need for" and "alternatives to" proposed hydroelectric dam projects must be assessed.
  6. Forest regions where future dams are planned do not yet have completed protected areas networks. Manitoba Hydro support of public policy for new protected areas has been cavalier. Land use planning, including lead by affected communities, would provide a basis for decisions about development.
  7. Most hydroelectric dams in Manitoba were over budget and finished late. Effects from the existing hydro system continue, did not only happen in the past.
  8. New hydroelectric dams require new transmission to link to the provincial grid system. Additional direct current transmission systems for export of power are being planned. Each transmission project requires a license. Direct current systems to move power south are not the same lines that connect new dams to the system.
  9. Manitoba Hydro is planning new transmission lines to connect the Manitoba grid to neighboring provinces (i.e. east-west power grid).
  10. When transmission lines traverse intact forest areas, the result is fragmentation of our forest landscape - which has significant impacts on wildlife habitat and species and potentially on Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal communities in the region (visit Roads and Corridors in Manitoba's Boreal for more information).


Manitoba Wildlands2002-2008